Pike
Written by Micheal Dwyer, 2023
Originally published in Spook Noodle Anthology, Volume 1.
It happened in July, several years back.
It was a beautiful night. The full moon was up, the
crickets were singing. Phil had snagged a bottle of
something out of his parents liquor cabinet. I want to
say it was vodka but I don’t remember. All I know is it
was gross. I don’t think any of us actually drank enough
to get a buzz.
When we parked at Oden we were the only car there. The
sun had been down for about an hour but the temperature
had hardly dropped. It was hot and humid, and we got it
into our heads that it was the perfect time for a swim,
so we took off running through the long grass and as we
came up into the woods one of us spooked a deer or
something. The noise made me jump a bit and that’s when I
took a wrong step in one of the mud holes and ate shit. I
was running full speed, and the fall was messy. I twisted
my ankle, skidded through a snowberry bush and scratched
my shin on an old stump.
Phil kept right on running, but Mikey stopped to help me
up. We had a good laugh about the giant skid mark I’d
left in the trail and then I told her to go on ahead and
I’d catch up. It’s not far from the mud holes to the lake
shore. Maybe a couple of minutes on good legs. It
probably took me about ten to catch up to them. When I
get up on the shore I can see two piles of clothes laying
next to the fire ring. The moonlight is bright on the
water and I can see Phil and Mikey floating probably
about fifty feet off shore. At that point I’m not sure I
want to go in. My ankle really hurts and I know those
scratches are going to sting in the water. But then I
hear Phil and Mikey splashing around out there and I
think there’s no way I’m missing this moment. Who knows
where any of us will be next year?
And with that in mind I start stripping down to my
underwear. I can hear them having a great time and I’m
just so excited to be doing this - so I don’t even bother
to take off my socks. Instead I just hobble into the
water and it doesn’t even matter that my ankle gives out
because I made it. I’m swimming. Night swimming. And it’s
exhilarating.
This is my first night swim at Oden, but I’ve been here a
thousand times in the daylight. Even in this eerie
moonlight, I know my way along the bottom. When I come
back up for air I’ve closed a little more than half the
distance to the others, but I can tell that something is
wrong. There’s a lot less splashing and I can hear Phil
half-choking. He’s calling for Mikey, and I have this
thought: what if she’d had more to drink than we
realized? What if she’s drowning? So I start calling for
her too.
I’m sure she was only under for a few seconds, but it
felt like years. When she did surface, she immediately
started doing this loud backstroke towards shore, all the
while screaming “Something bit me!” …
They say a bull shark can survive in fresh water and,
well, you don’t grow up around here without occasionally
wondering if one might swim hundreds of miles up the
Columbia and Pend Oreille rivers just to terrorize Bonner
County residents. Why not? Tourists drive hundreds of
miles here to do the same thing. Now I’m thinking shark,
but I’m also thinking that’s stupid and all the while
I’ve been instinctively swimming towards her. I’m almost
there when something rips me underwater.
It’s dark. Darker than it was on the swim out. Maybe it
was mud… or blood… or just the fear. I don’t know. It was
like the moonlight just left.
I can’t see anything but I can feel it clamping onto my
right leg just above the ankle. I start punching at that
whole area and somewhere in the flurry I must have scored
a good hit on the thing because I was suddenly on the
surface again. That’s when the pain hit me. It felt like
my ankle had been ripped open by a saw blade. I’m crying.
I’m yelling. And every time my face goes underwater I can
taste the blood that I know must be coming from me. I can
hear Phil asking if I’m alright but I know the answer is
probably no and I’m too terrified to think about it so I
just yell back that he needs to get Mikey to shore.
I’m the best swimmer here…
Phil is the worst…
But the bottom here is a really gentle slope. I know
he’ll be able to stand soon. That’s good, but what am I
going to do? I have one mutilated ankle, and one that’s
just sprained, and I’ve lost one of my socks. My sock! If
I can get go shore, I think, I can use my sock as a
tourniquet to stop the blood loss. I reach my arm out to
swim and that’s when the thing grabs my left forearm. My
right hand shoots out and grabs for a body, but it’s so
slimy that it slips and catches the spine of a fin. Not
a shark. It’s some kind of huge fish.
I ball my left hand up into a fist and pull. I can feel
everything in my arm being torn open and I know I’m
probably dead, but I’m not giving up without a fight. I
clap my right hand around the other side of the head and
then jab my whole finger into the eye socket.
It worked. The jaws release, and at the same time my left
foot lands on a rock. I push myself toward shore and then
somehow I’m on land. Phil is standing over me. He’s got
the sock wrapped around my forearm and he’s torquing it
down hard with a stick.
That’s all I remember. I blacked out after that.
When I woke up I was in a hospital bed. How Phil got
Mikey and I out of there I’ll never know. He doesn’t like
to talk about it. But he did tell me one thing. He said
that, as he was pulling me out of the shallows, the fish
came for me one more time. It was at least six feet long,
and well over a hundred pounds. He’d pulled me out just
in time, but in the moonlight he could see that it was a
pike. He said that when he looked at it, it looked right
back at him, and its one good eye shone
red in the
moonlight.